Breaking News

A Looming Challenge In Hilchos Shabbos

z2Halachic Musings

By Rabbi Yair Hoffman

Fifth-grade Bais Yaakov girls and gedolei ha’poskim in hilchos Shabbos finally have something in common. Both are very much excited about the popular Rainbow Loom bands—albeit for quite different reasons. For the poskim, finally after all these years, the esoteric melachos of meisach, oseh shtei batei nirin, oreg, and potzei’a have practical everyday application.

But let’s step back a bit to describe the latest craze that has hit not only the Bais Yaakovs but even the boys’ yeshivos. There are miniature weaving looms that colorful rubber bands are fitted onto, and the practitioners of this new pastime are now weaving colorful rubber-band jewelry.

The website states: “Rainbow Loom is a kit for making super fun rubber band links, recommended for 8 years to adult. Younger kids are recommended to use the kit with adult supervision (not for children 3 years or younger). Be sure to check out the instructions page to see a variety of ways to use the kit. Rainbow Loom is so new that new patterns are still being discovered.”

The new craze presents both challenges and opportunity. The challenges can be divided into three categories. We will go through each one.

The First Challenge

One challenge is that entire cadres of young girls and boys are now unwittingly violating four of the most obscure av melachos of Shabbos.

Meisach is setting up the loom. In our case, it is setting up the rubber bands on the plastic mini-loom. Other poskim hold that it is only when the loom is set up on the horizontal side that meisach applies. Regardless, meisach will be violated when the new jewelry is being woven.

Oseh batei nirin in theory is the setting up of the loom itself. The loom used in this modern manifestation works differently. It does not have back-and-forth pedals, but according to some of the explanations found in the Rishonim, the loom used would be a violation of oseh batei nirin too. Some poskim hold that the violation of oseh batei nirin involves merely passing the strings through the weaving machine.

There is also the melachah of oreg, which is the actual weaving. This can be violated even without a loom. The Rainbow Loom offers that possibility too. Indeed, from the fact that there are so many combinations, each different pattern can be a different violation of the above three av melachos.

The fourth category of prohibited melachah involving weaving is called potzei’a. This can involve removing the woven item from the loom, or removing one of the bands from the total bracelet.

Some would like to argue that because the main material being used is made of rubber bands, it is temporary and not a violation of the weaving melachos. However, most Rishonim understand that temporary means less than 24 hours. Experience shows that this is definitely not the case here.

The Second Challenge

There is yet another challenge here, unique to boys. Some of the items being created constitute jewelry, not merely bands. That being the case, the prohibition against wearing articles of clothing unique to women may be violated here. The prohibition is called “simlas isha” and may be tantamount to wearing a dress. We don’t want our yeshiva boys wearing dresses, so why are we letting them wear these decorative bracelets?

The Third Challenge

Finally, the last challenge involves bitul Torah. Many children are bringing these rubber bands and looms to school and working on them during class time. Yeshiva after yeshiva is finding that this has become a widespread problem.

The Opportunity

Notwithstanding all that was said above, the Rainbow Looms also offer tremendous opportunity. For the first time in close to two centuries, we now have an opportunity to teach the four most neglected areas of Hilchos Shabbos, these four av melachos, to an audience that is interested in and familiar with the weaving processes. We should rush to grasp it. v

The author can be reached at

Please ShareShare on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+Share on LinkedInShare on StumbleUponPin on PinterestEmail this to someone

Jewish Content

Posted by on October 24, 2013. Filed under In This Week's Edition. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

2 Responses to A Looming Challenge In Hilchos Shabbos

  1. Moshe Yehuda Gluck

    October 24, 2013 at 7:15 pm

    It is clear that these bracelets are being worn by boys and girls alike, making them not a simlas isha.

  2. dovid

    October 25, 2013 at 3:02 am

    i think it is very commendable for the Rabbanim to publicize this very real potential for chilul shabbos. It is very naive to belive that frum kids aren’t doing the loom on shabbos. Even a kid who is proficient in all the hilchos of shabbos (which unfortunately most are not) may not realize that this counts as weaving, having never seen weaving first hand. I recall my father telling us when he was getting his S’mecha he had to ask his mother to show him how to kasher meat since in shiur it was just theoretical and he wasn’t aware of the practical application of it. To a kid who just discovered another pattern it is very addicting to see if you can make that pattern as well. I know cause I myself have tried the loom and was thrilled that I was able to make a simple charm, and I am a pediatric doctor. A kid would just see this as a fun activity to do on a long Friday night or Shabbos day. Why would it occur to a child or even a teenager that this could possibly be a violation of not 1 but 4 different Avos Melachos of Shabbos. I would love to see a follow up to this article with the sources used and quoted by the Rabbanim about these issues