Breaking News

The Mantle Is The Message: The Color of Leadership

By Toby Klein Greenwald

These latest parashiot of the Torah readings remind me of the summer and fall of 2001, when the women of the Raise Your Spirits Theatre put on a production of Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat to sold-out audiences that came on bulletproof buses from all over Israel to our community center in Gush Etzion. The goal was to raise our own spirits and the spirits of others in the midst of a bloody intifada.

On opening night, 20 minutes to showtime, I found myself, as director, confronted by a problem of Solomonic proportions: Two little girls came to me in tears. Due to a miscount, we were one sheep-costume short, and each of them claimed the last costume. True, 30-some girls in the production were costumed in colored tunics as Jacob’s grandchildren, and there were more of those costumes available. But the ten “sheep”—an arbitrary number—dressed in burlap cloaks with cotton wool pasted on had the most-coveted roles. Go figure.

My solution: There were two acts in the play, so I suggested that the girls alternate at being a sheep. By next performance, I promised, we’d add another piece of burlap.

And the decision was good in their eyes.

Joseph’s brothers had, understandably, a more difficult time with their sibling’s colorful coat than did our two sheep with their rivalry over a costume. And no wonder: The coat that Jacob gave his favorite son (Bereishit 37:3) was not just a doting father’s extravagance. This was a conflict not just a over a garment, but over a role—not for a night, but for a lifetime.

The angry brothers knew exactly what Joseph’s coat represented, and it was not fashion or money or even fatherly love, painful as it was for them to discover that he was more favored than were they. Joseph’s coat stood for something they coveted more than all those things. The Renaissance-era Italian commentator Sforno states it the most explicitly: Joseph’s coat “was a sign that he would be a leader both in the home and in the field.”

Today, elementary business-communication seminars teach that more is remembered of a presenter’s appearance than of the content. But even in those days, ordinary shepherds understood the symbolism in Jacob’s gift. Howard Gardner, the renowned 20th-century educator and author of Frames of Mind, makes the point that there are seven or more forms of intelligence through which people think and learn—one of which is the visual. Joseph’s brothers certainly could think visually. No word or action of Jacob’s could have sent the message more clearly to his other sons than did a stunning piece of clothing: this son of his beloved Rachel would someday be their leader.

The most accepted understanding of the description of Joseph’s coat is that the pasim were strips of colored wool. Why not a coat of solid white, the quintessential symbol of purity? Because clothing is a metaphor for behavior, and white is for angels, not people. A coat of many colors, on the other hand, is a metaphor for what made Joseph a leader.

Behavior, like clothing, is external. It is the part of our personality that is visible. Philosophers who beat their wives, men of religion who abuse children, erudite pretenders to greatness—all garner our disdain. The leader’s cloak of actions—not his thoughts or beliefs—is what ultimately inspires others to follow him.

What, then, is the “color” of Joseph’s leadership? It is rich, complex, and multifaceted. Joseph becomes an economic leader in Egypt and, later, a caring and wise political leader of his brethren and their progeny. Joseph goes through a multitude of experiences and behaviors—from narcissism to fear to courage to faith to strength to repentance to forgiveness. These events and feelings not only prepare Joseph to be a leader, but are fed into the collective unconscious of the Jewish people through him.

There are two similar images in the Torah, showing that the multiple colors in Joseph’s coat are not incidental. One is the image of the rainbow that came out after the flood, G‑d’s way of assuring Noah that the world would never again be destroyed by water—a symbol of human survival. The other is the breastplate of the High Priest who served in the Temple as the spiritual leader of the Jewish people. The breastplate had 12 magnificently colored inlaid precious stones. It was worn by the individual who was deemed closest to G‑d, who was the symbol of spiritual fulfillment. Just as the rainbow’s message to the world foreshadowed the story of Joseph, so did the breastplate continue his message.

The common secret of the rainbow, Joseph’s coat, and the breastplate of the priest is that for a person to grow, develop, and survive as an individual, a member of a nation, and a citizen of the world, he must look to the colors and complexity within himself and within his sisters and brothers. For a nation to survive, it must regard this richness of variety not as a curse, but as a blessing.

We could certainly use a leader like Joseph today, whose swirling colored coat, like his open and loving heart in his adult years, symbolized and encompassed all the intricacy and seeking of the Children of Israel. v

Toby Klein Greenwald is a contributing editor for the Five Towns Jewish Times, the award-winning director of the Raise Your Spirits educational theater, and editor-in-chief of

Please ShareShare on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+Share on LinkedInShare on StumbleUponPin on PinterestEmail this to someone

Jewish Content

Posted by on December 7, 2013. Filed under In This Week's Edition. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed.