Heaven Scent 
Share

Heaven Scent 

On Shabbos, we read Parashas Toldot and learned the saga of Yitzchak giving his blessing to Yaakov. As Yaakov camouflaged himself with the coarse garments worn by his wayward brother, Eisav, Yitzchak was puzzled by the pious words and gentle voice of this son, whom he assumed to be the elder brother. Ultimately, the Torah relates how Yitzchak inhaled the scent of those garments and determined to go ahead with bestowing the blessing on Yaakov rather than Eisav for whom it was originally intended. Our Sages see in that verse a startling allusion. The Hebrew word for garment is “beged,” and it was that beged worn by Yaakov, putrid and rank with the scent of the field, blood, and countless other disturbing deeds, which convinced Yitzchak to bless Yaakov. Our Sages see in the word beged an allusion to the word boged, which means a betrayer or someone who deceives others. It is very puzzling in that we see that Yaakov indeed deceived his father into assuming he was Eisav. Yet, this Midrashic interpretation indicates that Yitzchak foresaw that later in history, there would be instances where Jews would betray others or would behave with treachery and somehow, this inspired him to award the blessing to Yaakov! What is the message and lesson of this Midrashic interpretation?

Long ago, when Jews in the Arabic countries were threatened with death unless they converted to Islam (much like the Jews of Spain were subjected to forced conversions), the Rambam wrote a letter to the Jews living in those lands. The letter is known as Iggeret HaShmad, the Letter on Apostasy. There were Rabbinic authorities who refused to accept back into their fold Jews who had given in to coercive threats and accepted Islam despite the option of giving up their lives to sanctify the Name of Hashem (Kiddush Hashem).

The Rambam, however, had a different view. He believed and ruled that despite their opting to feign fealty to another religion rather than accept martyrdom as their fate as halacha might require, these beleaguered Jews should be reintegrated into the faith. Their transgression must be viewed as a subterfuge, a camouflage, and the Jewish community must recognize that their inner spiritual loyalty remained with the Torah, to which they remained spiritually committed. Their “conversion” was only a disguise. This, writes the Rambam, is how we can interpret the Midrashic statement. Yitzchak inhaled the objectionable scent of Yaakov’s garments and he recognized that this was only “skin deep.” He realized that Yaakov was putting up a front as if he were Eisav, yet it was clear that deep down he was still Yaakov. Yitzchak also saw that there will be other times in the future when Jews would don disguises on the outside, yet remain Jewish within, even if this needs to be secretive. This is how the Rambam understood that when Yitzchak sensed the “betrayers,” he sought to strengthen such victims of coercion with a berachah. This is how the Rambam appealed to Jews to rethink the plight of their brethren who had faced the ultimate test and perhaps given in, but to retain some compassion for those who chose to survive through deception.

If we fast forward to our times and adopt the Rambam’s application of the Midrash about “blessing the bogdim,” how might our attitudes change about those Jews whose views and positions differ from our own? Do we continue to sense that latent fragrance beneath their sordid veneer? Do we place our hope in how they too will come around and realign with our traditions and beliefs as Observant Jews? Do we take steps to interact with those Jews who may not be “for us,” but are not necessarily against us? My late father, whose eleventh yahrzeit we just observed, often commented about our family’s Rosh Yeshiva, HaGaon Rav Simcha Wasserman, z’l, that he could see the good in another Jew even if he needed to use a microscope. Let’s hope that the time will come soon when our people unite once again. Yaakov will be Yaakov and not have to dress up and act like Eisav. Meanwhile, I think that there are some steps that each of us can take to make those changes easier for Jews who seek, deep within, to connect with their authentic Jewish identity. I will address these, iy’H, in future articles. n

Rabbi Dr. Dovid Fox is a forensic and clinical psychologist, and director of Chai Lifeline Crisis Services. To contact Chai Lifeline’s 24-hour crisis helpline, call 855-3-CRISIS or email [email protected]. Learn more at ChaiLifeline.org/crisis.