DATING FORUM
By: Baila Sebrow
Question
I’ve been dating for a number of years and have recently been meeting with professional shadchanim. While I pride myself on dressing well and being well-groomed, presenting myself in an optimal fashion, I’ve been terribly upset after meeting with several of these shadchanim. I’ve always considered myself to be of average weight but they are telling me that before they would consider setting me up, I must be even thinner.
This is utterly humiliating and demeaning, not just for me, but for all women. What happened to our focus on inner beauty, on middos tovos, on kindness and generosity? On spiritual growth and accomplishment? Since when did we become so narrow-minded and myopic that the entire focus has become our looks? And just who determined that thinner is more beautiful?
With the use of weight loss medications so rampant, many now assume that there’s no reason not to take off any excess pounds. But taking these meds is not a simple matter. There are side effects to consider. And the cost. So many factors play into this. It’s complicated. And I’ve heard that the use of these medications is causing an increase in eating disorders in our communities. It’s creating havoc, especially among our teenage girls who are feeling the pressure as they approach the dating years.
How can we turn the tide back? I’m afraid for the future. How did this happen to the People of the Book? We’ve lost our way! How can we get back on the right path? We need to redirect ourselves. We’ve lost our proper focus.
Any suggestions you can present would be most appreciated.
Thank you
Response
I wish I could tell you that your experience is unusual, but unfortunately, I hear variations of this complaint far too often. Frankly, I find it disturbing. Let’s start with something that should not have to be explained: A woman is not a number on a scale. She is not a dress size, a photograph, or a measurement. She is a human being with feelings, aspirations, intelligence, middos, qualities, and so much more to offer. When someone walks away from a meeting with a shadchan feeling humiliated because she was told she needs to lose more weight before she can be considered for a shidduch, something is terribly wrong.
I understand that physical attraction plays a role in dating. I’m not suggesting that people should disregard attraction or that everyone should be attracted to everyone. We all have preferences, and there’s nothing inherently wrong with that. But there’s a tremendous difference between having personal preferences and making someone feel that her appearance disqualifies her from being worthy of consideration. The question one might ask is: When did the shidduch process become so heavily focused on outward appearance? And when did we get to a point where a person’s weight can overshadow everything else about her?
I’ve been involved in shidduchim for most of my life, and I’ve seen many changes in the dating world. Some have been positive, but others have taken us in a direction that I find downright disturbing. We have become increasingly preoccupied with superficial details. Height, weight, hair, clothing, photographs, and a list of physical requirements that sometimes reads more like a casting call than an effort to find a marriage partner. These issues have become more of a problem since the advent of pictures accompanying résumés. Singles and their parents commonly dissect every feature and aspect of the young lady’s (or man’s) face and body.
It isn’t just the singles who are responsible. Parents have a role in this, too, particularly the parents of young singles entering the shidduch arena. In other words, sometimes the expectations being placed on young men and women are not even their own. They are also expectations handed down by grandparents, relatives, friends, and an entire social environment that has become obsessed with appearance.
I’ve seen how much pressure this creates. Young women are made to feel that they must look a certain way before they can even enter the dating world. Some become so preoccupied with their weight that it affects their confidence, self-esteem, and their ability to enjoy life. Imagine beginning the journey toward marriage already believing that you’re not good enough. That is a terrible message to send to Bnos Yisrael.
And now we have entered another chapter in this story: the widespread use of weight-loss medications. I’m not here to judge anyone who uses medication under appropriate medical supervision. Each person’s circumstances are different, and medical decisions should be made between an individual and her healthcare provider. But we cannot pretend that these medications are a simple solution to a complicated issue. There are medical considerations, potential side effects, costs, and questions about long-term use. They are not lifestyle accessories, nor should anyone feel pressured to take pharmaceuticals simply to meet somebody else’s dating criteria.
More importantly, we need to be careful about the message we are sending to teenagers. When girls grow up hearing that thinner is always better, that a few extra pounds can stand between them and a shidduch, and their appearance is always being evaluated, we should not be surprised when body image becomes a source of anxiety and stress. We need to take that seriously. Eating disorders and unhealthy relationships with food are not matters to dismiss as teenage drama. The pressure to achieve an unrealistic appearance can have very real consequences. Parents, educators, principals, and community leaders need to recognize what is happening before more young people are hurt.
I also want to address the shadchanim. A shadchan has a responsibility that goes beyond collecting information and making introductions. We are dealing with people’s lives, emotions, hopes, and vulnerabilities. A conversation with a shadchan can stay with a person for years. A careless comment about someone’s weight, appearance, or perceived shortcomings can do tremendous damage. If a shadchan believes that a particular match would not be appropriate because of a physical preference expressed by the other party, there are ways to communicate that without humiliating the person. There is no reason to make a woman feel that she must change her body before she deserves to be considered for marriage. I would encourage shadchanim to examine their own standards. Are we advocating for the singles who come to us, or are we simply reinforcing whatever unrealistic expectations are being placed before us? Are we looking at the entire person, or are we allowing a photograph and a few physical measurements determine whether someone gets an opportunity?
We also need to stop confusing physical perfection with marital compatibility. A successful marriage is not based on a perfect waistline. It is based on respect, emotional maturity, communication, shared values, kindness, commitment, and the ability to weather life’s challenges together. Someone who is beautiful on the outside but lacks the ability to be a caring, considerate, and responsible spouse is not necessarily a better marriage prospect than someone whose appearance may not fit somebody else’s narrow definition of beauty.
And what about the young men? They are also not immune to these pressures. Men are also judged by height, weight, build, hair, income, and other expectations. I’m sorry to say that the frum world has created an environment in which both genders can feel as though they are being evaluated rather than getting to know another human being. That is not a healthy foundation for dating.
So how do we turn the tide? First, parents need to take a hard look at the expectations they are communicating to their children. We need to raise young people who understand that taking care of themselves is important, but their worth is not determined by their appearance. We should encourage healthy habits, not create an atmosphere of constant scrutiny. Second, shadchanim need to remember that they are dealing with human beings, not products being presented to prospective buyers. Every person deserves dignity. If we want singles to trust us with something as personal as their search for a spouse, we must treat them with sensitivity and respect. Third, our community leaders, rabbanim, educators, and schools need to address this issue openly. People spend so much time discussing the shidduch crisis, yet they sometimes overlook the very culture that makes the process so difficult. We cannot continue to tell young people that marriage is important while simultaneously creating an environment in which they feel they must achieve a particular physical appearance to be considered.
And finally, singles need to understand that they should never allow another person’s narrow standards to determine their self-worth. Of course, they should all strive to take care of themselves, present appropriately, and make an effort. But there’s a difference between self-improvement and feeling compelled to change yourself because you’re afraid nobody will want you otherwise.
I want to address one more point in your letter: your question about what happened to the People of the Book. It’s a question worth asking. We are a people who place tremendous emphasis on Torah, middos, chesed, tznius, and the development of a person’s character. We teach our children about the importance of kindness, humility, and judging others favorably. Yet somewhere along the line, some of those values seem to have vanished when it comes to the shidduch process.
We can discuss a person’s family, education, hashkafah, accomplishments, and character, but if the first conversation revolves around whether she is thin enough, we need to stop and ask ourselves what we’re really prioritizing. There’s nothing wrong with wanting to be attracted to the person you marry. But there is something wrong when we allow the physical expectations to become so overwhelming that we lose sight of the person in front of us.
Singles should be looking for someone with whom they can build a home, share a life, raise a family, and grow together. They should be looking for someone who will be there when life becomes difficult, when appearances change, if illness chas v’shalom comes, when the years take their toll, and when the superficial things that once seemed so important no longer matter. Because they won’t matter nearly as much as the person you married.
I have always believed that shidduchim should be about bringing people together, not making them feel inadequate. We need to restore some perspective, sensitivity, and common sense to the dating process and focus less on judging and measuring. A good place to start would be spending more time looking at the person behind the photograph. Perhaps the next time someone asks a shadchan whether a young woman is thin enough, they should remind themselves to ask a much more important question: Is she the kind of person with whom someone can build a beautiful Jewish home? Because ultimately, that is what we should be striving for, because we cannot claim to be building Jewish homes while teaching an entire generation that they must first change their bodies to deserve one.
Baila Sebrow is president of Neshoma Advocates, communications and recruitment liaison for Sovri-Beth Israel, executive director of Teach Our Children, and a shadchanis and shidduch consultant. Baila also produces and hosts The Definitive Rap podcast for 5townscentral.com, vinnews.com, Israel News Talk Radio, and WNEW FM 102.7 FM HD3, listenline & talklinenetwork.com. She can be reached at [email protected].


