Longing For The Music Of My Youth
By: Yochanan Gordon
[Author’s Note: I wrote this article a week ago. In that time, with continued thought, my views have begun to shift a little. I could have scrapped this piece altogether and updated it; instead I decided to run it and also write a follow up for next week as a way to demonstrate the full arc of my thoughts and emotions on this subject. Therefore, I present the first piece in the series on the music of my youth as the genesis of a reflection between where my love of music began and its trajectory up until today. Please read and enjoy.]
Everything about the music today is different from the music I grew up on. The music itself is vastly different and the way we consume it and the manner in which it is released to the world bears no resemblance to the way that it was once done.
Full albums are far and few between. In most cases artists are releasing singles or EPs of three songs. An artist who has a series of eight to ten songs to release at once will do so at a rate of one song per week over a series of weeks, not to overwhelm the listener.
As you’ll soon see, I have been a lifelong fan of Avraham Fried. My 12th grade son in MAY recently came home saying that his rebbi insists that he was the biggest Avraham Fried fan ever. Since then, I’ve been waiting for parent-teacher conferences so we can once and for all settle this debate.
I grew up in the golden years of Jewish music. Obviously, Shlomo Carlebach was still descending upon stages as the patriarch of modern Jewish music. Diaspora was still within the conversation. Abie Rottenberg with Journeys and Dveykus was producing masterpiece after masterpiece with music that did not only entertain but educated generations as well. Yerachmiel Begun and the Miami Boys Choir were laying the groundwork for what is now known as Jewish Music history. My father, the trailblazer in Jewish radio that he was, had featured Carlebach and Diaspora a number of times on his morning radio program recorded in East Orange NJ.
Of all the elements within music in general, I have always been deeply impacted by the art of vocals. In my mind there was no Jewish singer who had the range and vocal texture that Avraham Fried had. Even at a very young age I was drawn to songs like “Emes” and “Ani Ma’amin,” both of which had chazzanic interludes.
I remember very clearly the release of the Bracha V’hatzlacha album, that came out prior to our eighth-grade graduation trip to Cleveland. I can recall sitting on a coach bus being driven to and around Cleveland, listening to the cassette tape of Bracha V’hatzlacha on a Walkman. Songs like “Sisu V/simchu B’simchas Hageulah,” “Chavivi,” “Don’t Hide from Me,” “Odom Doeg,” “Yesimcha Elokim,” “Yerushalayim Oro Shel Olam,” and “Kshem She’Ani.” I mean when do you have an album where practically every song is a hit?
Thinking about it now, it’s a miracle that my soul didn’t expire from the experience of listening to all those songs in one sitting. MBD’s English album. I mean, there were few things as enjoyable as sitting and listening to that solid gold album. MBD’s voice was in its prime. The songs packed strong messages presented with musical genius. It is difficult to describe to someone who wasn’t there when it first dropped.
Avraham Fried often talks about his guidance from the Lubavitcher Rebbe during the formative years of his musical career. As I am thinking about it now, these songs were produced in the early ‘90s when the Rebbe was concretizing the idea of Moshiach and empowering the Jewish world that it was within our capability to realize. With grandparents and cousins in Crown Heights we’d often drive through the Chassidic enclave and see the street banners welcoming Moshiach and the Mitzvah Mobiles and for a young child it imparted the dream of redemption to me in a really strong way.
I remember being given the Chazak album as a Sukkos gift on chol ha’moed. I locked myself in my room and listened to the entire compact disc (CD) from beginning to end. Chazak has the distinction of being the best-selling album in Jewish music history. I believe at the time it sold over 100,000 copies in the first year. The hits on that album were: “Chazak,” “Udvorov,” “Didoh Bei,” “Tiher Rebbe Yishmael,” “Hashata Hacha,” “Modeh Ani,” “Teka,” “Mah Yedidus,” and “Levinyomin.” It’s hard not to list every song but these songs are such an integral part of my formative years.
A few years after that My Fellow Jew was released to the world. I was then in Mesivta and I listened to that entire album in a single sitting in my friend’s dorm room, focusing on every musical nuance as if it was a Rashi or a Tosfos. I would go so far to say that I remember every vocal diyuk on these albums as well as I did when they were released.
However, while I was longing for the music, it wasn’t really for myself. I can listen to these songs whenever I want. The truth is that there have been times when on long trips I asked whoever was manning the CarPlay to put on some of the old MBC albums. Of course, kids cannot admit that their parents’ generation was better or more advanced than the current one. I know I am going to make some people’s blood boil with this reference, but it all goes back to the perennial question of Jordan versus Lebron.
The irony is: Shlomo HaMelech writes in Ecclesiastes: “Don’t say, what was it about the previous generation that made it so much better than these days, for the question is not a wise one.” Yes, it is a clear proof from the wisest of all men that assuming the previous generations were better or more virtuous is a false supposition. However, what it does demonstrate is that the prevailing notion throughout history was that the previous generations were better and more virtuous and today that notion has been turned on its head.
As I sat there, lost in longing for the music of my youth, again, it wasn’t for me; it was for a generation today that doesn’t know what Abie Rottenberg’s music did for the world that we grew up in. There was a mystique and a magic that was produced in the duo of Yossi Green and Avraham Fried and it is that duo in particular that pulled me so intensely then that I long for today.
In basketball there were certain dynamic duos who were instrumental in shaping NBA history: Larry Bird and Kevin McHale, Magic Johnson and Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, John Stockton and Karl Malone, Shawn Kemp and Gary Payton. These were people who knew the routes, could anticipate the moves of their teammates in advance, and could be counted upon to get the ball to where it needed to be faster than the defense could react.
If basketball isn’t your thing: There are teachers and students through whom the teachings of a particular sage were released to the world that we are benefiting from today decades and even hundreds of years later. Where would our world be today without Rebbe Nachman finding his prized student Rebbe Nosson of Nemirov? Reb Yoel Kahan and the Lubavitcher Rebbe. Notwithstanding the fact that Reb Yoel had assembled a series of scribes who together transcribed the Rebbe’s farbrengens, it was Reb Yoel himself whom the Rebbe trusted to be able to flesh out the true nekudah that the Rebbe brought out in a given sicha or maamar. We almost take for granted the hundreds of volumes of the Rebbe’s Torah that are extant due to that communion of souls.
Have you ever thought for a moment what would have been had Reb Yoel not been there, or wasn’t in the right frame of mind to process and direct the team who would then put it out? I saw in a sefer that the duo of Rebbe Nachman and Rebbe Nosson was longed for in the world from the genesis of creation. It’s not arbitrary. It had to be. And although the transmission of Torah is much more critical than the music of Avraham Fried or MBD, still I believe that these partnerships were similarly not arbitrary.
The truth is that it has been a long time since Avraham Fried featured Yossi Green on the cover of one of his albums. It has been a while since Avraham Fried has released a full album but even longer since he and Yossi Green lit up the ears of music listeners the way in which they did in the decades that I was brought up in, and it is a different world because of that.
I expressed this idea to my close friend Elimelech Blumstein of TYH and he heard me and felt the passion in my words, but he feels that the music of yesterday would not resonate in today’s world as it did years ago. He even made a very bold statement that he said I could repeat in his name. He said that he loves the tunes of his youth very much and is similarly indebted to those responsible for bringing them to our ears and in the world, but “if ‘Tanya’ was released today for the first time it wouldn’t resonate the way it did when it came out decades ago.”
Let that sink in for a moment.
For me that was a tough pill to swallow. It is funny that I am expressing that since I began by saying that there are no similarities between the music of my childhood and that of today’s. However, the fact of the matter is that many of these songs are generational songs, which I believe is a distinction that no longer exists. I would maintain that the best songs of today’s era by its very definition will be short-lived. So to me, considering the fact that songs that were originally released thirty plus years ago are still very much a part of the modern music repertoire and songs of today literally go in one ear and out the other, doesn’t it follow logically that the music of yesterday could still be impactful in today’s day and age?
Despite the lucidity of my logic even I agree that the music that I long for in Avremel and Yossi and some of the other phenoms of yesteryear is not a type of music tailored to today’s audience.
However, some of the music of Fried and MBD pushed the envelope in their time and that compelled some of the more sensitive listeners to Abish Brodt or some other more traditional musicians. If they were able to exhibit a cutting-edge approach in their prime, then why can’t they do so today while straddling the fence between what is modern and traditional?
There is context behind the release of the song “Mi Mah” on the Bein Kach Ubein Kach album, which indicated that it was initially beyond the realm of comfort for Avraham Fried. But the trust between the two artists compelled Fried to record and release it. Music continues to be produced at a never-before-seen frequency in an unprecedented range of genres, yet somehow the mystique over the music of my youth remains despite the options that exist today.
In the last couple of days, I came across a recent video of Yossi Green at a piano with Avraham Fred singing alongside him and it gave me a glimmer of hope.
Then today I saw a new release, a collaboration between Avraham Fried and Ari Stern on a song composed by Yossi Green and it led me to believe that G-d is feeling what I’m feeling.
In the parashah of Pesach Sheni the Torah writes, “Mi shehaya tameh oh baderech rechoka v’lo yachlo l’asot at hapesach b’moado.” Contrary to what some might say, we are not tameh, but we are baderech rechoka.The question that I’ve been asking on behalf of this generation is lamah nigrah? At the time this question was originally asked, Moshe said, “Imdu ve’eshma mah yetzaveh Hashem lachem,” which means the response was immediate and positive. We are hoping for a similar outcome this time around. n
Yochanan Gordon can be reached at [email protected]. Read more of Yochanan’s articles at 5TJT.com.


